WALL STREET JOURNAL April 8, 2013
The U.S. housing market has
broken out of a deep slump, and prices are shooting up faster than anyone
thought possible a year ago. For many homeowners, that is a cause for
celebration.
Nick Timiraos explains how
the Federal Reserve keeping interest rates low is causing home prices to grow
faster than they normally would during a recovery, and that has some experts
worried. Photo: Getty Images.
But the speed at which prices are rising is prompting
murmurs of concern that the Federal Reserve's campaign to reduce interest rates
could be giving the housing market a sugar high.
Prices
of existing homes rose 10% in February nationally from a year ago. They have
been rising during the seasonally slow winter months—and they show signs of
jumping further as the spring buying season gets under way. What's going on?
Prices of existing homes
rose 10% in February nationally from a year ago. Above, a home in Mariemont,
Ohio.
First, inventories of homes available to buy have fallen
to 20-year lows. Home builders have added little in the way of new construction
since 2008. Banks are selling fewer foreclosures. Investors have scooped up
more homes, converting them to rentals.
Many borrowers, meanwhile, aren't willing or able to sell
at prices that are down sharply from their 2006 highs, despite a greater
inclination among banks to approve short sales. Tight lending standards mean
some owners will hold back from selling because they aren't sure they would
qualify for a mortgage on their next home.
Demand has also revved up, first from investors buying
homes below their replacement costs, and later as rising rents and falling
interest rates encouraged more first-time buyers to purchase homes that have
monthly payments that are less than what it costs to rent.Improving home-price expectations have also unleashed pent up demand. The U.S. added around 1.3 million households a year for the 10-year period ending in 2007, after which household formation fell to more than half that level. Household formation was lower in the five years following the housing bust than any period since the 1960s, according to Altos Research, an analytics firm in Mountain View, Calif.
But the population never stopped growing. Households simply doubled up. Between 2008 and 2010, the country had around two million households that "couldn't wait to launch on their own," says Mike Simonsen, chief executive of Altos Research. Many of those new households have been renters, but more are opting to buy.
The upshot is that, in a reversal from just two years
ago, demand is outstripping the available supply. Even though sales volumes
could be constrained this year by low inventories, some economists say prices
are set to soar. "A lot of folks are realizing, 'Wow, there is no second
wave of foreclosures. Interest rates if anything could head up. Prices are
rising. If I'm going to get in I better get in now,'" says Christopher
Thornberg, a housing economist with Beacon Economics in Los Angeles.
The impact of low mortgage rates is profound. Before the
Fed began buying mortgage-backed securities in late 2008, rates for 30-year
fixed mortgages stood at around 6.1%, and a borrower who could qualify for a
$1,000 monthly payment could get a $165,000 mortgage. Today, that same
borrower, at a 3.5% rate, can borrow as much as $222,000. In other words, the
Fed's low-rate campaign has increased purchasing power by a third.
So is this the beginning of another bubble? Not really.
For now, home prices on a national basis are still below their long-run average
relative to incomes. "The recovery is solid. There are pure fundamentals
you can point to," says John Burns, chief executive of a real-estate
consulting firm in Irvine, Calif.
But he says the housing market is turning up sharply,
"hockey-sticking faster than it otherwise would," because of
investors, low inventories and low mortgage rates. The worry is that if prices
keep rising at their current pace, "we're going to have a real
affordability problem" once rates move above 6%, says Mr. Burns.
Buyers face a dilemma: paying more for a home today,
compared with a year ago, or paying even more tomorrow at a time when interest
rates might also be higher.
"It's
been a lot slower process than we had hoped it would be, and things were getting
a lot more expensive," says David Fritsche, a retired architect who lost
bids on six properties in the past six months before closing last week on a
home in Rancho Santa Margarita, Calif. He and his wife, Darlene, want to be
closer to their daughter's family but plan to hang onto their old home in
Phoenix for a few years.
While prices may be rising on the back of the Fed's easy
money, tighter credit standards are acting as a brake on the recovery. High
unemployment, low savings, and high debt loads among those who would like to
buy their first homes will also remain a drag.
The housing sector is finally healing. But the sector may
be in for more volatility until there is more demand from—and credit for—people
who want to buy homes that they plan to live in.By Nick Timiraos - The Wall Street Journal
No comments:
Post a Comment